Pies

Every Sugaree’s pie starts with our homemade, traditional lard and butter crust (southern grandmother approved!). We work directly with local growers to make fresh fruit pies during harvest periods, and all of our pies are packed to the top with rich, flavorful fillings.

Sort by

Filter by

Lemon Pie Bar

Lemon Pie Bar

$3.50
A slice of pecan pie with a vintage pie server on a silver platea pecan pie plated next to a plant with one slice missing

Pecan Pie

$6.75 - $55.00
Sweet potato pie on a blue cloth next to yellow flowers

Sweet Potato Pie

$6.25 - $50.00
A slice of pecan pie with a vintage pie server on a silver platea pecan pie plated next to a plant with one slice missing

Pecan Pie

$74.00
Sweet potato pie on a blue cloth next to yellow flowers

Sweet Potato Pie

$69.00
Multiple pies on a metal table top with different traysPecan Pie and Chess Pie

Choose Your Own Pie 2-Pack

$135.00
Close up on a slice of chocolate meringue pieA small and large chocolate meringue pie on trays next to a plant

Chocolate Meringue Pie

$17.50 - $45.00