Local Pickup

Because some things are just too southern to get anywhere else (or at least harder to ship), our most extensive selection of Sugaree’s cakes, pies, and baked goods are reserved for Mississippi locals and travelers lucky enough to visit downtown New Albany.

Sort by

Filter by

Slice of caramel cake on a concrete countertop and light pink cloth

Cake by the Slice

$2.50 - $5.00
Turtle cheesecake slices stacked on a white plateLarge tray of turtle cheesecake

Turtle Cheesecake

$3.00 - $33.00
Strawberry cupcake on a white plateStrawberry cupcakes on a green countertop

Strawberry Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Chocolate Chip Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$2.25
Double DooziesDouble Doozies

Double Doozies

$3.00
Sugaree’s wedding cookies gift boxSugaree’s Wedding Cookies dusted with powdered sugar on a floral-patterned plate

Wedding Cookies

$0.50 - $27.00
Person holding a sausage pinwheel in front of Sugaree's bakerySausage pinwheels on a white plate next to two cups of coffee

Sausage Pinwheels

$4.25
Two six packs of chocolate cupcakes on a teal countertopChocolate cupcakes on a teal countertop

Chocolate Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Chocolate chip walnut cookies stacked inside a wooden shelf next to a spool of yarnChocolate chip walnut cookies on a concrete countertop

Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies

$2.25
Vanilla cupcake on a white plateVanilla cupcakes on a green countertop

Vanilla Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Red Velvet cupcake on a white plateRed Velvet cupcakes on a green countertop

Red Velvet Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Ding Dong CupcakesDing dong cupcake with bite taken out of it
Weekly Special

Ding Dong Cupcakes

$2.50 - $28.00

Available Thursdays-Saturdays

Half of a chocolate cake and vanilla cake with sprinkles on a wooden countertop

Cake by the Half

$17.00 - $35.00
Stacked tea cakes on a white plateTea cakes next to a cup of coffee and cream
Sold out

Tea Cakes

$0.75
Coconut Cupcake being frosted with sky high marshmallowy icing using a piping bagCoconut cupcakes on a green countertop

Coconut Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Beveragesplaceholder

Beverages

$0.75 - $2.75
Person holding a plate of strawberry tartsStrawberry tarts on a blue plate next to a blue tablecloth

Strawberry Tarts

$1.50
Italian cream cupcake on a white plateA dozen Italian cream cupcakes in a plastic tray on a green countertop

Italian Cream Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Lemon Pie BarsLemon Pie Bars
Sold out

Lemon Pie Bars

$3.50
Blackberry tarts on a white tray Blackberry tarts on a pink tray next to wildflowers and a cloth towel

Blackberry Tarts

$1.50
German Chocolate Macaroon

German Chocolate Macaroon

$2.75
six pecan tassies plated on a grey countertopa plated pyramid of pecan tassies atop a blue cloth napkin

Pecan Tassies

$2.25 - $15.00
Person holding a plate of turtle tartsTurtle tarts on white and pink plates on top of a brown table cloth
Sold out

Turtle Tarts

$2.25
Plain brownies squares on a white plateTray of plain brownies on a marble countertop

Plain Brownies

$2.00 - $22.00
Stack of three turtle brownies on a white plateTurtle brownies on dark gray and light gray plates with silverware

Turtle Brownies

$2.50 - $27.00
Various types of Sugaree's cupcakes on a green countertop

Sampler Cupcakes

$14.00 - $28.00
Stacked oatmeal raisin cookies on a white plateStacked oatmeal raisin cookies on a wooden shelf

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

$2.25
Oatmeal toffee cookies stacked on a wooden shelf

Oatmeal Toffee Cookies

$2.25
Peanut butter cookies stacked on a white platePeanut butter cookies stacked on a wooden shelf

Peanut Butter Cookies

$2.25
No Bake Cookie
Weekly Special

No Bake Cookie

$1.50

Available Wednesdays & Thursdays

Assorted Sugaree’s cookies and tarts on decorative plates on a textured surfaceMedium giftbox unpacked w/ assorted desserts

Gift Basket, Medium

$47.00
Chocolate, strawberry and vanilla cupcakes on cooling rackChocolate, strawberry and vanilla cupcakes on glass and ceramic plates

Neapolitan Cupcakes

$14.00 - $28.00
Assorted small Sugaree’s cookies and tarts with a ribbon on a textured surfaceSmall gift box assorted Sugaree's desserts on tray

Gift Basket, Small

$31.00
Small dessert tray with assorted Sugaree's desserts

Dessert Tray (9-inch)

$22.50
Large dessert tray with assorted Sugaree's dessertsAssorted Sugaree’s small cookies and brownie bites on a round stone platter with a gray background

Dessert Tray (12-inch)

$40.00
Gold coffee bag

High Point Coffee

$4.50 - $15.00
Sugaree’s Divinity Pecan Log in gift wrapA mini Sugaree’s Pecan Log on a pink floral plate

Pecan Log

$6.00 - $15.00
Large chocolate chip cookie on a tray next to stainless steel containers of flour and sugarLarge chocolate chip cookie on a tray next to stainless steel containers of flour and sugar

Big Chocolate Chip Cookie

$18.00 - $30.00
ApronsAprons

Aprons

$75.00
Caramel CakeCaramel Cake
Sold out

Caramel Cake

$55.00
Sugaree’s Coconut Cake on a marble cake stand with a wooden baseCoconut Cake

Coconut Cake

$55.00
Cream Cheese Pound CakeCream Cheese Pound Cake
Oprah’s O List Pick

Cream Cheese Pound Cake

$30.00
Small cookies, pies and slices of cakeSugaree’s brownies, tassies, tarts and more on white plate with gift wrap packaging and ribbon

Gift Basket, Large

$67.50
Slice of Sugaree’s Italian Cream Cake showing three layers with white frosting, pecans, and pineapple in backgroundSugaree’s Italian Cream Cake with white frosting and crumbly nut topping on a white plate

Italian Cream Cake

$65.00
Strawberry CakeStrawberry Cake

Strawberry Cake

$55.00
Chocolate, rainbow, Italian cream, strawberry, red velvet, cream cheese pound cake and Southern caramel cake slices on white, pink and teal platesAssorted Sugaree’s Sampler Cake slices in a box with different flavors and toppings

Sampler Cake

$65.00
Red Velvet CakeRed Velvet Cake

Red Velvet Cake

$55.00
Rainbow CakeRainbow Cake

Rainbow Cake

$55.00
Chocolate cake on a tray next to a green vase with red rosesChocolate Cake

Chocolate Cake

$55.00
White shirt with Sugaree's Logo

T-Shirt, Sugaree’s Logo

$20.00
Blue shirt with cake on cake stand graphic and sugarees sugarees there ain't no cake I'd rather eat text

T-Shirt, “Ain’t No Cake”

$20.00
Blue shirt with man with beard and sunglasses with bake it bake it text

T-Shirt, “Bake It”

$20.00
Blue Shirt with Rainbow Cake Graphic and Baked with Pride in New Albany Mississippi text
Sold out

T-Shirt, “Baked with Pride”

$20.00
Yellow Shirt with Spatula Graphic and Text if they cake don't get ya the icing will

T-Shirt, “Icing Spatula”

$20.00
A small and large chocolate meringue pie on trays next to a plantChocolate Meringue Pie
Weekly Special

Chocolate Meringue Pie

$17.50 - $45.00

Available Fridays & Saturdays

Key Lime BarsKey Lime Bars

Key Lime Bars

$3.50