Multiple pies on a metal table top with different trays

Shipping Item

Choose Your Own Pie 2-Pack

$135.00

Fall Season Exclusive

With this amazing pack, dessert for your holidays and any gathering are taken care of. Choose two of Sugaree’s classic Southern pies. You can double up on your favorite, Pecan Pie or Sweet Potato Pie, or mix and match flavors and get one of each!

Flavor One:

Flavor Two:

Variant

Shipping Information

Ships nationwide for a flat rate per box of up to two cakes. Our cakes freeze well, so shipping two is always a better deal!
Rates are calculated at checkout based on your destination and the available service you select.
Sugaree’s ships Mon-Fri each week, and cakes can be on your doorstep Tues-Sat.
Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
We reserve the right to schedule shipments EARLIER, but not later.

Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ and Shipping Terms and Conditions page or contact us at 1-866-SUGAREE.

Scratch-made, Southern Goodness

Our Southern family recipes use European butter, fresh eggs, and premium ingredients.

Perfect for Parties & Gifting

From birthdays and weddings to office parties and reunions, we’ll help make every gathering a little sweeter.

Convenient Scheduling

Pre-order in advance and ensure your desserts are party-ready when you are.

Phone Orders Welcome

Need help? Call 1-866-SUGAREE for assistance from our friendly bakery staff.

Do It for the Graham (Oops, We Mean ’Gram)

Join @SugareesBakery on Facebook, TikTok & Insta

Follow @SugareesBakery to see our latest bakes, sales, and events in your feed.
Tag us to share your Sugaree’s moments with us and the world!

Choose Your Own Pie 2-Pack

Location access is blocked.

Load the map