Time Honored Southern Layer Cakes

From picnic blanket to white linen, Sugaree’s cakes carry Southern sweetness wherever they go. Our family recipes go back generations, and we honor them by using only simple, from-scratch, locally-sourced ingredients. We hope to see you soon at Sugaree’s Bakery. If you can’t make it, no worries – we ship nationwide.

Sugaree's Bakery Header
Sugaree's Bakery Header

Our Best-Selling Cakes

Visiting us for the first time? We know it can be hard to choose from so many delicious cakes. Why not start with one of our customer favorites? You’ll just have to decide if you’re in a buttery mood or a sugary mood!

Slice of chocolate cake on a plate next to a green vase with red rosesChocolate cake on a tray next to a green vase with red roses

Chocolate Cake

$46.00 - $69.00
A moist chocolate cake with rich chocolate buttercream icing, you may not be able to eat anyone else’s chocolate cake again.
Rainbow cakes on blue cardboard traysRainbow cake sitting on a tray covered in rainbow sprinkles

Rainbow Cake

$52.00 - $79.00
Perfect for birthday parties and other festive events, our Rainbow Cake has five different colored and flavored butter layers (strawberry, orange, lemon, lime, grape) and is topped with cream cheese...
Slices of red velvet cake on platesRed velvet cake on a red cake stand in front of a wooden wall

Red Velvet Cake

$46.00 - $69.00
Red Velvet Cake’s are a southern staple and the moist, barely chocolate, not-too-sweet layers of cake are spread with an old fashioned cooked icing that combines sugar, milk, butter, and...
Italian cream cake slices on blue platesItalian cream cake on a tray with green plants

Italian Cream Cake

$52.00 - $79.00
This Italian Cream Cake features three layers of coconut, pecan, walnut butter cake layered with fresh pineapple, cream cheese icing and pecan sprinkles.

A Taste of Tradition

MADE-FROM-SCRATCH RECIPES

Every cake is handmade in our New Albany bakery, using traditional family recipes, with a little sass thrown in here and there. There’s no mass production. Our bakery isn’t big enough for that, and our baker wouldn’t allow it.

Premium Ingredients

If your grandmother didn’t have it in her kitchen, you won’t find it in our cakes. The distinct character of each of our confections comes from the authenticity of our ingredients, the alchemy of our recipes, and the care we put into
each cake.

Southern-Style Sweetness

For people from around here, we’re a taste of home that will remind you to share a fond memory. For those farther off, you’ll taste an authentic, regional take on the cake.
Or rather, many takes. Classic Southern sweetness is sometimes coy and sometimes bold, but it’s always dressed for the occasion.

As Seen In

the Oprah Magazine logo
Huff Post Logo
Southern Living logo
The New York Times logo
Garden & Gun logo
Saveur logo

More Sugaree’s Desserts

assorted cupcakes

Cupcakes

Our cupcakes are made with the same delicious recipes we use for our layer cakes – just in bite size versions! Well, they might be a bit bigger than bite size... unless you’re an alligator.

A small and large chocolate meringue pie on trays next to a plant

Pies

Every pie starts with our homemade lard and butter crust. We always use locally-grown pecans, sweet potatoes, and strawberries. Southern Living put our chocolate meringue pie on their “Top Ten Best Southern Pies” list!

assorted brownies

Brownies & Bars

Our brownies are rich and moist — not too cakey, not too fudgy. We use very high quality chocolate and butter for all of our bars.

assorted cookies and tarts

Cookies

We’ve collected recipes from family and friends (like Ms. Voncile, a lunchroom lady known for her tea cakes) to make our cookies and we use high quality chocolate, local pecans, and European butter.

Cakes on display outdoors

Gifts & Special Occasion Bakes

Celebrate with Sugaree’s! From birthday cakes to gift baskets, party trays, smash cakes, and more, Sugaree’s has memorable, delicious desserts for every giftable moment or special event.

Locally-Made Aprons

Looking Oh So Cute in the Kitchen

We carry simply the prettiest tea towel aprons made by our owner and founder herself, and they’re perfect for gifting.

Each design is one-of-a-kind and features functional and fashionable pockets, contrast edging, embroidery, and other delicate details.

Handmade aprons bring joy to your kitchen

Enjoy Sugaree’s Any Day, Any Way

Local pickup

LOCAL PICKUP

Stop by our downtown New Albany, Mississippi bakery.

Mail Order

MAIL ORDER

Enjoy our cakes nationwide with 2-day and overnight shipping.

Special Occasions

SPECIAL OCCASIONS

Sweeten a birthday, wedding, or other to-do with a special cake.

Wholesale

WHOLESALE

Find Sugaree’s in a specialty store near you.

Corporate gifting

CORPORATE GIFTING

Surprise and delight your employees or clients on any schedule.

Fundraising

FUNDRAISING

Make support for your cause irresistible by selling Sugaree’s cakes.

Destination Delicious – Stay Overnight in Our Loft

Be our guest and eat our treats in the vacation rental loft(s) above Sugaree’s New Albany café. Our historic small town will refresh you, and you’ll be ideally positioned for an Ole Miss game day, a regional tour of blues sites, or a day trip to Memphis.

Sugaree’s in a Store
Near You

You can find a slice of Sugaree’s — or a whole cake — in finer retail stores across the Mid-South.

Location map

Do It for the Graham (Oops, We Mean ’Gram)

Join Sugaree’s on Facebook & Insta

1. Follow @SugareesBakery to see our latest bakes, sales, and events in your feed.

2. Tag @SugareesBakery to share your Sugaree’s moments with us and the world.

3. Use #SugareesBakery for a monthly chance to win a cake!