In-Store Selection

Cakes, cupcakes, pies, brownies, and bars – oh, my! Our downtown bakery always offers a dazzling mix of Sugaree’s staples as well as a rotation of daily specials and seasonal goodies.

Sort by

Filter by

Slice of caramel cake on a concrete countertop and light pink cloth

Cake by the Slice

$2.50 - $5.00
placeholder

Beverages

$0.75 - $2.75
Strawberry cupcake on a white plateStrawberry cupcakes on a green countertop

Strawberry Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Chocolate Chip Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$2.25
Turtle cheesecake slices stacked on a white plateLarge tray of turtle cheesecake

Turtle Cheesecake

$3.00 - $33.00
Bowl of wedding cookies on top of a marble countertopSugaree’s wedding cookies gift box

Wedding Cookies

$0.50 - $15.00
Two Double Doozies on parchment paperSeven plated Double Doozies with a cup of coffee on a concrete countertop

Double Doozies

$3.00
Two six packs of chocolate cupcakes on a teal countertopChocolate cupcakes on a teal countertop

Chocolate Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Person holding a sausage pinwheel in front of Sugaree's bakerySausage pinwheels on a white plate next to two cups of coffee

Sausage Pinwheels

$4.25
Chocolate chip walnut cookies stacked inside a wooden shelf next to a spool of yarnChocolate chip walnut cookies on a concrete countertop

Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies

$2.25
Red Velvet cupcake on a white plateRed Velvet cupcakes on a green countertop

Red Velvet Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Stacked tea cakes on a white plateTea cakes next to a cup of coffee and cream

Tea Cakes

$0.75
Half of a chocolate cake and vanilla cake with sprinkles on a wooden countertop

Cake by the Half

$17.00 - $35.00
Vanilla cupcake on a white plateVanilla cupcakes on a green countertop

Vanilla Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Unwrapped coconut cupcakes on black plates with a blue backgroundCoconut cupcakes on a green countertop

Coconut Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Italian cream cupcake on a white plateA dozen Italian cream cupcakes in a plastic tray on a green countertop

Italian Cream Cupcakes

$2.00 - $24.00
Lemon Pie Bar

Lemon Pie Bar

$3.50
Sugaree’s mini chocolate meringue pieSugaree’s mini chocolate meringue pie
Seasonal Special

Chocolate Meringue Pie

$16.00 - $40.00
German Chocolate Macaroon

German Chocolate Macaroon

$2.75
Plain brownies squares on a white plateTray of plain brownies on a marble countertop

Plain Brownies

$2.00 - $22.00
Stack of three turtle brownies on a white plateTurtle brownies on dark gray and light gray plates with silverware

Turtle Brownies

$2.50 - $27.00
Person holding a plate of turtle tartsTurtle tarts on white and pink plates on top of a brown table cloth

Turtle Tarts

$2.25
Various types of Sugaree's cupcakes on a green countertop

Sampler Cupcakes

$14.00 - $28.00
Stacked oatmeal raisin cookies on a white plateStacked oatmeal raisin cookies on a wooden shelf

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

$2.25
No Bake Cookie
Weekly Special

No Bake Cookie

$1.50

Available Wednesdays and Thursdays

Peanut butter cookies stacked on a white platePeanut butter cookies stacked on a wooden shelf

Peanut Butter Cookies

$2.25
Oatmeal toffee cookies stacked on a wooden shelf

Oatmeal Toffee Cookies

$2.25
Slice of caramel cake on a concrete countertopCaramel cake on a metal tray and concrete countertop

Caramel Cake

$55.00
Slices of cream cheese pound cake on white plates with floral prints, next to a bowl of strawberriesCream cheese pound cake on a white tray on a wooden table
Oprah’s O List Pick

Cream Cheese Pound Cake

$30.00
Slice of coconut cake on a plate next to a plantCoconut cake on an aqua colored plate next to a plant

Coconut Cake

$55.00
Small dessert tray with assorted Sugaree's desserts

Dessert Tray (9-inch)

$22.50
Close up of a strawberry cakeStrawberry cake on a white tray next to a vase of flowers

Strawberry Cake

$55.00
Sliced pecan log on a white traySugaree’s Divinity Pecan Log in gift wrap

Pecan Log

$15.00
Chocolate covered strawberries on a white plateChocolate Covered Strawberries
Seasonal Special

Chocolate Covered Strawberries

$18.00 - $30.00
Large dessert tray with assorted Sugaree's desserts

Dessert Tray (12-inch)

$40.00
A slice of pecan pie with a vintage pie server on a silver platea pecan pie plated next to a plant with one slice missing

Pecan Pie

$6.75 - $55.00
Chocolate, strawberry and vanilla cupcakes on cooling rackChocolate, strawberry and vanilla cupcakes on glass and ceramic plates

Neapolitan Cupcakes

$14.00 - $28.00
Slices of red velvet cake on platesRed velvet cake on a red cake stand in front of a wooden wall

Red Velvet Cake

$55.00
Slice of chocolate cake on a plate next to a green vase with red rosesChocolate cake on a tray next to a green vase with red roses

Chocolate Cake

$55.00
Medium giftbox unpacked w/ assorted desserts

Gift Basket, Medium

$47.00
Chocolate, rainbow, Italian cream, strawberry, red velvet, cream cheese pound cake and Southern caramel cake slices on a teal plateChocolate, rainbow, Italian cream, strawberry, red velvet, cream cheese pound cake and Southern caramel cake slices on white, pink and teal plates

Sampler Cake

$65.00
Small gift box assorted Sugaree's desserts on tray

Gift Basket, Small

$31.00
Gold coffee bag

High Point Coffee

$4.50 - $15.00
Sweet potato pie on a blue cloth next to yellow flowers

Sweet Potato Pie

$6.25 - $50.00
Rainbow cakes on blue cardboard traysRainbow cake sitting on a tray covered in rainbow sprinkles

Rainbow Cake

$55.00
ApronsAprons

Aprons

$75.00
Italian cream cake slices on blue platesItalian cream cake on a tray with green plants

Italian Cream Cake

$65.00
Large chocolate chip cookie on a tray next to stainless steel containers of flour and sugarBig Chocolate Chip Cookie

Big Chocolate Chip Cookie

$18.00 - $30.00
Heart Shaped CookieHeart Shaped Cookie

Heart Shaped Cookie

$18.00 - $30.00
Small cookies, pies and slices of cake

Gift Basket, Large

$67.50
Big Heart Shaped Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie

Big Heart Shaped Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie

$18.00 - $30.00
Strawberry Ganache CakeStrawberry Ganache Cake
Seasonal Special

Strawberry Ganache Cake

$75.00
Yellow Shirt with Spatula Graphic and Text if they cake don't get ya the icing will

T-Shirt, “Icing Spatula”

$20.00
White shirt with Sugaree's Logo

T-Shirt, Sugaree’s Logo

$20.00
Blue Shirt with Rainbow Cake Graphic and Baked with Pride in New Albany Mississippi text

T-Shirt, “Baked with Pride”

$20.00
Blue shirt with man with beard and sunglasses with bake it bake it text

T-Shirt, “Bake It”

$20.00
Blue shirt with cake on cake stand graphic and sugarees sugarees there ain't no cake I'd rather eat text

T-Shirt, “Ain’t No Cake”

$20.00